An interesting argument but not, we suspect, the final word.


The assumption of this book is that the soul, an intangible item, resides at a specific tangible location in the body. This is something akin to saying that the universe is infinite but our galaxy is located in the middle of it. As a description of early experimentation on the nervous system – some of it little more than barbarism fueled by the hubris of the enlightenment – this is a profoundly interesting book. At a biological level the discoveries formed a basis for further work that may mitigate the horror of strokes and catastrophic injuries. When you leave the purely physical side of things you tread on dangerous ground. The ONLY surgical procedure to alter behavior that has a 100% success [sic] rate is the frontal lobotomy! Never mind the fact that diagnosing illnesses of the mind is as subjective as necromancy but consider that EVERY mind altering drug that has been developed has so many and such varied side effects that the cure may be worse than the curse. On balance the book is worth reading but do keep a salt shaker handy as much of it needs to be taken with a pinch of salt.

Soul made flesh : the discovery of the brain and how it changed the world  Carl Zimmer New York : Free Press, c 2004  Brain History Hardcover. 1st ed. and printing. xii, 367 p. : ill. ; 24 cm. Includes bibliographical references (p. 325-348) and index. Clean, tight and strong binding with clean dust jacket. No highlighting, underlining or marginalia in text. VG/VG

Soul Made Flesh is the remarkable untold story of a dramatic turning point in history — the exciting discovery of how the human brain works. In an unprecedented examination of how the secrets of the brain were revealed in seventeenth-century England Carl Zimmer tells an extraordinary tale that unfurls against a deadly backdrop of civil war, plague, and the Great Fire of London. At the beginning of that turbulent century, no one knew how the brain worked or even what it looked like intact. By the century’s close, the science of the brain had taken root, helping to overturn many of the most common misconceptions and dominant philosophies about man, God, and the universe. Presiding over the rise of this new scientific paradigm was the founder of modern neurology, Thomas Willis, a fascinating, sympathetic, even heroic figure who stands at the center of an extraordinary group of scientists and philosophers known as the Oxford circle. Chronicled here in vivid detail are their groundbreaking revelations and often gory experiments that first enshrined the brain as the chemical engine of reason, emotion, and madness — indeed as the very seat of the human soul.

Zimmer tells the story of this scientific revolution through the lives of a colorful array of alchemists, mystics, utopians, spies, revolutionaries, and kings. He recreates the religious, ethical, and scientific struggles involved in the pioneering autopsies of the brain carried out by Thomas Willis; the discovery of the circulation of blood by William Harvey and his flight from London with his besieged king, Charles I; René Descartes’s persecution by Catholics and Protestants alike for his views of the brain and soul; and the experiments and personal dramas of gifted men who forever changed the way science is practiced as they simultaneously upended our view of our human selves and our place in the world.

In this distant mirror to our own time of continuing scientific revolution and worldwide social upheaval, Zimmer brings to life the painstaking, innovative discoveries of Willis and his contemporaries — the taproots of the amazing work of today’s neuroscientists, who continue to explore the brain, revealing the hidden workings of emotions, memories, and consciousness. Graced with beautiful illustrations by Christopher Wren, Soul Made Flesh conveys a contagious appreciation for the wonder of the brain, its structure, its many marvelous functions, and the implications for human identity, mind, and morality. It is the definitive history of the dawn of a world-changing science and attitude — the age of the brain and modern consciousness.

Advertisements

Comments Off on An interesting argument but not, we suspect, the final word.

Filed under Book Reviews

Comments are closed.